Boyfriend picking time....

So it's that time again and we are deciding who we should match our Cabela up with. She should be going into heat anytime now and we are getting excited at the prospect of puppies. My decision now is, who? Last time we used Jake, but it wasn't successful and we had NO puppies, just a dog that was loving all the extra food we were giving her because we thought she was pregnant. But, I have been on KSL and found another dog I like, so help me decide. Probably no one will respond because that's what happended the last time I did this but....What do you guys think?

Jake...

Or
The new guy...

Here's our Cabela, isn't she cute......